ProbateTrustee Duties

Understanding Undue Influence

By November 10, 2026No Comments
Undue Influence
A parent changes their trust shortly before dying. A caregiver suddenly inherits most of the estate. Or a family member who controlled your loved one’s finances ends up receiving property that should have gone to someone else.
These situations may raise questions about undue influence in California, particularly when the changes seem inconsistent with someone’s previously expressed wishes.
Not every unexpected inheritance decision involves wrongdoing. However, California law allows heirs and beneficiaries to challenge a will or trust when someone improperly influenced the person who signed it.
At The Grossman Law Firm, Attorney Scott Grossman represents California heirs and beneficiaries in probate and trust litigation, including disputes involving suspected undue influence.

Table of Contents

Key Takeaways

  • Undue influence occurs when excessive persuasion overcomes someone’s free will and produces an unfair result.
  • The California probate courts examine vulnerability, authority, manipulation tactics, and the fairness of the outcome.
  • Evidence may include medical records, communications, witness statements, and suspicious changes to a will or trust.
  • Heirs and beneficiaries may have grounds to challenge documents created through undue influence.
  • Strict deadlines can apply, particularly when contesting a California trust.

What Is Undue Influence in California?

Under California Probate Code § 86 and Welfare and Institutions Code § 15610.70, undue influence involves excessive persuasion that overcomes another person’s free will and results in an inequitable outcome.
For example, an older parent may depend on an adult child for transportation, medication, and access to financial information.
That dependency alone doesn’t establish undue influence.
However, if the child uses that control to pressure the parent into changing a trust for the child’s financial benefit, the circumstances may warrant investigation.
The real question is whether the decision was what your loved one truly wanted or the result of someone else’s pressure.
If you suspect undue influence affected your loved one’s will or trust, The Grossman Law Firm can help you understand your rights and determine whether you have grounds to take legal action.

What Are the Signs of Undue Influence in a Will or Trust?

California courts consider four factors under Welfare and Institutions Code § 15610.70.

1. Vulnerability of the Person

Courts examine whether illness, age, cognitive impairment, isolation, or dependency made someone more susceptible to manipulation.
A dementia diagnosis may be relevant, but it doesn’t automatically prove undue influence.

2. Authority of the Alleged Influencer

The court considers whether the person accused of undue influence held a position of trust or authority.
This might involve a caregiver, family member, financial adviser, or someone managing the person’s daily affairs.

3. Actions Used to Influence the Decision

Warning signs may include:
  • Isolating someone from family or friends.
  • Controlling access to medication or information.
  • Pressuring someone to sign documents quickly.
  • Keeping changes to a will or trust secret.
  • Using intimidation, threats, or emotional pressure.

4. Whether the Result Was Unfair

A court may examine whether the final distribution differs substantially from earlier documents or the deceased person’s expressed intentions.
However, an unequal inheritance alone is not sufficient to establish undue influence.

Example: A Caregiver Receives Most of the Trust

Consider this hypothetical situation.
After her father’s death, Jennifer, who lives out of state, discovers that his trust was amended six months before he died.
For years, the trust divided his estate equally between Jennifer and her brother.
The amendment changes everything.
A caregiver who had been living with their father now receives his $900,000 house and most of his financial accounts. Jennifer and her brother receive relatively little.
Jennifer finds out the caregiver is controlling her father’s appointments, keeping family away, and even set up the meeting where he signed the amendment.

Could Jennifer Challenge the Trust?

Jennifer may have a good reason to look into whether her father’s trust was changed because of undue influence.
She would want to know if her father really understood the changes, if the caregiver pressured him, and why the inheritance was changed so much.
The caregiver’s involvement and financial benefit could be significant evidence. Depending on the relationship and applicable statutory exceptions, Probate Code § 21380 may also create a presumption of fraud or undue influence for certain transfers to care custodians of dependent adults.
The amendment doesn’t become invalid just because it’s suspicious. Jennifer would need to show there is a legal reason to challenge it.

How Do You Prove Undue Influence in California?

Proving undue influence often requires examining what happened before the will or trust was signed.

Evidence That May Support Your Claim

Useful evidence can include:
  • Medical records: Information about cognitive impairment, illness, or vulnerability.
  • Earlier wills or trusts: Documents showing how inheritance provisions changed.
  • Text messages and emails: Communications suggesting pressure, threats, or isolation.
  • Witness testimony: Observations from relatives, friends, caregivers, or professionals.
  • Financial records: Transactions showing whether the alleged influencer personally benefited.
A California probate litigation attorney can evaluate how these records support the legal elements of a claim.

Who Has the Burden of Proof?

Under Probate Code § 8252, someone contesting a will generally bears the burden of proving undue influence.
However, a presumption may shift the burden in certain circumstances.
In Rice v. Clark (2002), the California Supreme Court identified circumstances involving a confidential relationship, active participation in obtaining the document, and an undue benefit that may support such a presumption.
Probate Code § 21380 also establishes presumptions for certain transfers, subject to exceptions.

Can Undue Influence Invalidate a Will or Trust?

Yes. Under Probate Code § 6104, a will or affected provision may be ineffective if it was procured through undue influence.
A successful challenge to a trust amendment may also invalidate the affected provisions.
Depending on the circumstances, earlier valid documents may control how property passes.
The final result depends on what evidence there is and which parts the court decides are not valid.

How Long Do You Have to Challenge a Trust?

Under California Probate Code § 16061.8, a person properly served with the statutory trustee notification generally has 120 days from service to contest the trust.
If the person receives a copy of the trust terms during that period, the deadline may extend to 60 days after delivery, whichever is later.
Will contests must follow different procedural rules and deadlines.
Because these deadlines can affect your ability to pursue a claim, speak with a California probate or trust litigation attorney promptly if you suspect undue influence.

FAQ

Can a Family Member Be Guilty of Undue Influence?

Yes. A family member can be guilty of undue influence if they pressure someone into making decisions that aren’t really their own.

Is Dementia Enough to Prove Undue Influence?

No. Dementia can make someone more vulnerable, but you usually need more proof to show there was undue influence.

Can You Challenge a Trust After Someone Dies?

Yes. Certain people can challenge a trust after someone dies, but there are deadlines and rules to follow.

Can You Sue for Undue Influence on Contingency?

Some cases involving undue influence can be handled on a contingency fee, depending on the facts and what’s at stake.

How The Grossman Law Firm Can Help

If you believe someone manipulated a loved one into changing their will or trust, The Grossman Law Firm can help assess whether you have grounds to challenge those changes.
At The Grossman Law Firm, we help beneficiaries and heirs throughout California enforce their rights in probate and trust litigation.
Call (888) 443-6590 or fill out our Get Help Now form.
Our Intake Specialists can evaluate your case at no cost. Qualifying cases will be scheduled for a Free Phone Consultation with Attorney Scott Grossman.
Originally Published: August 12, 2024