Back to the Learning Center

By: Scott Grossman on May 20th, 2024

Can You Sue a Trustee for Negligence?

When a loved one passes away, the emotional toll can be overwhelming. Navigating the complexities of probate and trust administration adds another layer of stress, especially if you suspect the trustee—the person responsible for managing the trust—may be negligent. This article will guide you through understanding trustee negligence, your legal options, and the steps to take if you decide to pursue legal action. For over twenty years, The Grossman Law Firm has been here to provide clear, compassionate information to help you during this difficult time.

What is Trustee Negligence?

Definition of Negligence in Trust Administration

Trustee negligence occurs when the trustee fails to fulfill their duties according to the expected standards, harming the trust or its beneficiaries. So, yes, you can sue a trustee for negligence. Trustees have a fiduciary duty to manage the trust prudently, act in the beneficiaries’ best interests, and adhere to the trust document’s terms.

Common Examples of Trustee Negligence

Examples of trustee negligence include:

  • Mismanagement of trust assets, such as poor investment decisions.
  • Failing to distribute assets according to the trust terms.
  • Inadequate record-keeping and reporting.
  • Ignoring the beneficiaries’ needs and communications.

Legal Grounds for Suing a Trustee

Breach of Fiduciary Duty

A trustee’s fiduciary duty is paramount. Breaching this duty by acting in self-interest, neglecting trust terms, or failing to act with due care can form the basis of a lawsuit.

Breach of Trust

When a trustee fails to adhere to the specific instructions within the trust, they commit a breach of trust. That could involve distributing assets improperly or ignoring particular instructions about asset management.

Conflict of Interest

Trustees must avoid conflicts of interest. If a trustee stands to benefit personally from their management of the trust, this can be grounds for a lawsuit.

Failure to Properly Manage Trust Assets

Trustees must manage trust assets prudently. That means making informed investment decisions, keeping thorough records, and ensuring the trust assets are adequately maintained and managed.

Beneficiary Rights in California

If you would still like more information on what exactly qualifies as a breach of fiduciary duty, check out our article “20 Ways Your Trustee can be breaching their fiduciary duties” on our website. If you have more questions about your beneficiary rights and what you should know moving forward. 

Recognizing the Signs of Trustee Negligence

Inadequate Communication

A trustee should maintain regular and transparent communication with beneficiaries. An indicator of negligence typically results in a lack of communication or unresponsiveness.

Poor Financial Management

Signs of poor financial management include unexplained withdrawals, missing funds, or investments that seem imprudent or reckless.

Unexplained Delays

Delays in distributing assets or providing accountings without valid reasons may suggest negligence.

Lack of Transparency

Trustees are required to keep accurate records and share relevant information with beneficiaries. A lack of transparency or refusal to provide documentation is a red flag.

Steps to Take Before Suing a Trustee for Negligence

Reviewing the Trust Document

Carefully review the trust document to understand the trustee’s duties and obligations. The review will help determine if there has been a breach.

Documenting Evidence of Negligence

Gather all relevant documentation, including communication records, financial statements, and any other evidence supporting your negligence claim.

Communicating Concerns with the Trustee

Before pursuing legal action, communicate your concerns directly with the trustee. Sometimes, discussion and clarification resolve the issue.

Seeking Mediation or Alternative Dispute Resolution

Mediation can be a less adversarial and more cost-effective way to resolve disputes. Consider this option before proceeding to court.

How to File a Lawsuit Against a Trustee

Choosing the Right Attorney

Select an attorney who specializes in trust and probate law. Their expertise will be crucial in navigating the complexities of your case.

Understanding the Legal Process

The legal process can be lengthy and complex. Your attorney will guide you through filing the lawsuit, discovery, and potential trial.

Preparing Your Case

Your attorney will help you gather and organize evidence, prepare legal arguments, and strategize for potential defenses from the trustee.

Possible Outcomes of the Lawsuit

Outcomes can vary. The court may order the trustee to compensate for losses, remove the trustee, or provide other remedies to address the negligence.

Challenges in Suing a Trustee for Negligence

Proving Negligence

Proving negligence can be challenging. You must demonstrate that the trustee’s actions directly harmed the trust or beneficiaries.

Trustee Defenses

Trustees may argue that they acted in good faith, followed the trust terms, or that the beneficiaries suffered no actual harm. That is why it is vital to get a copy of the trust to ensure it wasn’t breached. 

Emotional and Financial Costs

Litigation can be emotionally draining and financially costly. Consider these factors before deciding to sue.

Alternatives to Litigation

Mediation and Arbitration

These alternative dispute resolution methods can provide a quicker and less contentious resolution to your dispute.

Removal and Replacement of the Trustee

Sometimes, it may be possible to petition the court to remove and replace the trustee without suing for damages.

Settlements and Negotiations

Negotiating a settlement with the trustee can be a practical solution that avoids the time and expense of a lawsuit.

The Role of the Probate Court

How Probate Courts Handle Trustee Negligence Cases

Probate courts oversee trust administration and handle disputes involving trustee negligence. They can remove trustees, order compensation, and enforce trust terms.

Timelines and Procedures

The court process involves specific timelines and procedures, including filing deadlines, hearings, and potentially a trial.

Court Remedies and Sanctions

Courts can impose various remedies, including financial compensation, removal of the trustee, and other sanctions to address the negligence.

Preventing Future Trustee Issues

Choosing a Reliable Trustee

Select a trustee who is trustworthy, competent, and capable of managing the trust responsibly.

Regular Trust Reviews and Updates

Regularly review and update the trust document to reflect your current wishes and circumstances.

Educating Beneficiaries on Their Rights

Educate beneficiaries about their rights and the trustee’s duties to prevent future issues.

Next Steps for Trustee Negligence

Suing a trustee for negligence is a serious decision that requires careful consideration and preparation. Understanding your legal options and the steps involved can help protect your loved one’s legacy and ensure the trust is managed correctly. If you suspect trustee negligence, seeking professional guidance from an experienced attorney is crucial. We are here to help you navigate this complex process with compassion and expertise.

Need more information on Trust Litigation? To ensure they follow their fiduciary duties, check out our complete Overview of California Trust Litigation on our website. If you have more questions about your rights as a Beneficiary and what you should know moving forward. 

Please contact our law firm  at (888) 443-6590, if you have questions or need assistance with trust administration issues. Our firm is dedicated to helping you achieve a fair resolution and safeguarding your family’s future. It’s best to reach out as soon as possible. The longer you take, the more damage your trust could take. 

If you are still having some trouble, have any more questions, or want to talk to someone about your case, please give us a call or fill out our Get Help Now form below.